Rewriting a logical statement with multiple quantifiers I am currently reading "Discrete Mathematic

pipantasi4

pipantasi4

Answered question

2022-07-08

Rewriting a logical statement with multiple quantifiers
I am currently reading "Discrete Mathematics with Applications" by Susanna Epp. Not all questions have answers in this book. I stumbled upon question 11 from Section 3.3
Let S be the set of students at your school, let M be the set of movies that have ever been released, and let V(s,m) be "student s have seen movie m." Rewrite the following statement without the symbol , the symbol or variables.
s S and t S such that s t and m M , V ( s , m ) V ( t , m )
I interpreted this as "There are two students who watched all released movies". Is it right? If yes why do we need an if-then operator? If not what is the correct way?

Answer & Explanation

Alexia Hart

Alexia Hart

Beginner2022-07-09Added 19 answers

Step 1
As I expressed in the comments, your interpretation is not correct. "There are two distinct students such that if a certain student has seen a movie then the other student has also seen that movie" is correct. Your error probably came from thinking that m M meant that the students saw all the movies in existence. Rather, try to think of it as a "for any" than a "for all". The if-else means that if one student has seen the movie, the other student has seen it too, and this is valid for any movie in existence.
Step 2
EDIT: I tried making it more clear that is only a one-way conditional, instead of a biconditional, but Mark Saving's phrase “There are two distinct students, one of whom has seen all of the movies that the other has seen.” is much more clear than mine.

Do you have a similar question?

Recalculate according to your conditions!

New Questions in Discrete math

Ask your question.
Get an expert answer.

Let our experts help you. Answer in as fast as 15 minutes.

Didn't find what you were looking for?