Explain why. (a) Z_9 is not isomorphic to Z_3 times Z_3. (b) Z_9 times Z_9 is not isomorphic to Z_9 times Z_3 times Z_3.

Suman Cole

Suman Cole

Answered question

2021-09-19

Explain why (a) Z_9 is not isomorphic to Z_3 × Z_3.
(b) Z_9 × Z_9 is not isomorphic to Z_9 × Z_3 × Z_3.

Answer & Explanation

liingliing8

liingliing8

Skilled2021-09-20Added 95 answers

a)Notice that 1 is of order 9 in Z9. Every element of Z3*Z3 is of order 1 or 3. truly let (a,b)Z3Z3,(a,b)=/(0,0)(so that its order is not 1.) Then 3(a,b)=(a,b)+(a,b)+(a,b)=(3a,3b)=(0,0) so it is of order 3.
Suppose that these groups are isomorphic, and let φ be some isomorphism.
Then φ(3)=φ(1+1+1)=φ(1)+φ(1)+φ(1)=3φ(1)=0
since φ(1) is an element of Z3*Z3. This means that 1 is in kernel of φ, which means that φ is not in injective (φ is injective if and only if ker φ={0}, since 0 is the neutral element of Z9, which 1 is not.) This is a contradiction since φ was supposed to be an isomorphism!
Thus, Z9 an Z3*Z3 are not isomorphic.
b)Notice that a ∈Z9 is of order 9 if and only if geg(a,9)=1. Thus 1,2,4,5,7,8 are of order 9. thus 6 of them.
Now, (a,b) ∈ Z9*Z9 is of order 9 if and only if a is of order 9 and b is of order 9. Thereforem there are 96+69=54+54=108 element of order 9.
On the order hand, (a,b,c)Z9Z3Z3 is of order 9 if and only if a is of order 9, so there are 6*3*3=54 such elements.
Now suppose that φ:Z9Z9Z9Z3Z3 is an isomorphism. Then aZ9Z9 is of order 9<φ(a)Z9Z3Z3 is of order 9 (isomorphisms preserve the order of the element). However, this is impossible, since Z9Z3Z3 has less elements of order 9 than Z9*Z9. Thus, there exists no isomorphism Z9Z9Z9Z3Z3.

Do you have a similar question?

Recalculate according to your conditions!

Ask your question.
Get an expert answer.

Let our experts help you. Answer in as fast as 15 minutes.

Didn't find what you were looking for?