Aluffi's proof that
\det(AB)=\det(A)\det(B)
for commutative rings
1) How does \mathbb{Z} being initial
crealolobk
Answered question
2022-01-13
Aluffis
Answer & Explanation
Jordan Mitchell
Beginner2022-01-14Added 31 answers
Step 1
If and are in , where R is a commutative unitary ring, then there is a homorphism
such that
for
and
If one proves that for the matrices
,
respectively
,
then apply to this relation and get
But you know that
holds for matrices X, Y whose entries are in a field. This is why the book suggests to look at these matrices in the field of fractions of the ring
Raymond Foley
Beginner2022-01-15Added 39 answers
Step 1
Prove that
for square matrices A, B over any integral domain.
First question:
Here is the main point: Consider the ring
.
Suppose you have two polynomials such that .
Then, for any ring R, we can interpret f(x) and g(x) as polynomials in . Moreover, f(x) and g(x) continue to be equal as polynomials in . Thus, by considering the evaluation map, you can substitute as elements from the ring R and you have an identity.
For example, we have the polynomial equality
in this leads to the fact that
in any (commutative and unital) ring.
Step 2
The formal proof of this is obtained by using the fact that given elements , there is a well-defined (unique) homomorphism such that . (The initial-ity of in Ring determines the map on the level of the constants uniquenely.)
To apply it to your case, note that the and can be viewed as polynomials in (when you set all the entries of A and B to be interdeterminates) and you have shown that they are equal there. Thus, they are equal over any ring.
alenahelenash
Expert2022-01-24Added 556 answers
Step 1
A Bourbaki-proof: You may use the exterior product to prove the formula for any two matrices A,B (of the same rank) over any commutative unital ring:
Let
be a free R-module of rank n and let
be -matrices with coefficients in R (R any commutative unital ring). It follows
are R-linear endomorphisms of the rank one free R-module
It has the property that
is multiplication with the element .
From this it follows since is a functor (see the below link) that