We want to prove that (Z_7,\oplus) is group. I have difficulty proving associativity axiom. Th

Jaylyn Villarreal

Jaylyn Villarreal

Answered question

2022-04-17

We want to prove that (Z7,) is group. I have difficulty proving associativity axiom. The solution reads
Let aZ7,bZ7 and cZ7. By Theorem 3.4.10 we only need to show
(a+(b+c))bmod7=((a+b)+c)bmod7.
This holds since a+(b+c)=(a+b)+c for all integers a, b, and c by the associative property of the integers. Hence  is associative.

Therorem 3.4.10. Let a and b be integers, and let m be a natural number. Then 
 (a+b)modm=((amodm)+(bmodm))modm

Answer & Explanation

xmzdenisemst0

xmzdenisemst0

Beginner2022-04-18Added 6 answers

The point of the theorem 3.4.10 is that you can take the mod additionally at any point in your calculation without changing the result. This should make it clear intuitively that the statement is true.
If you want to be very formal, you can continue your calculation
a(bc)=(a+(b+c)mod7)mod7 =(1)(amod7+((b+c)mod7)mod7)mod7 =(2)(amod7+(b+c)mod7)mod7 =(3)(a+(b+c))mod7,
which is exactly the claim the solution makes (after you do the same exact calculation for (ab)c). For (1) and (3), we used the theorem, for (2) notice that mod7 is applied twice to b+c in the second line, which is unnecessary.

CyncgotoCancey1k6

CyncgotoCancey1k6

Beginner2022-04-19Added 6 answers

Step 1
If what you are looking for is an intuitive approach, you can appreciate if you imagined a clock with only 7 numbers; let those numbers be 0,…,6. Adding 2 different hours h1,h2, no matter in which order, will always give you the same hour in the clock. This is what theorem 3.4.10 states.
Step 2
Now, from a formal definition, associativity of an operation in a group is defined as a(bc)=(ab)c, and that is what "suffices" you to prove. However, if what you mean is that why does it also imply a+(b+c)mod7=a+b+cmod7 comes from extending your theorem 3.4.10 to that particular case.

Do you have a similar question?

Recalculate according to your conditions!

Ask your question.
Get an expert answer.

Let our experts help you. Answer in as fast as 15 minutes.

Didn't find what you were looking for?