Statistical significance: Test for different (small) sample sizes? I recently finished my simulatio

Yesenia Sherman

Yesenia Sherman

Answered question

2022-06-22

Statistical significance: Test for different (small) sample sizes?
I recently finished my simulations which I now need to statistically analyse. I am comparing mean firing rates (FR) of neurons in the same population (Pop1) before and after I change the connectivity probability (Pconn).
I have n=140 observations/simulations for the network with the natural connectivity state, but I have only n=5 observations/simulations for the network with varied connectivity.
(I am arbitrarily changing the Pconn, while measuring the FR of a population before and after the change. n=140 observations correspond to BEFORE and n=5 observations correspond to AFTER the change)
I am quite unsure in which statistical test should I use to determine the significance of my results, since the sizes of samples vary so much. Can anyone suggest a solution?
Thanks in advance

Answer & Explanation

Punktatsp

Punktatsp

Beginner2022-06-23Added 22 answers

Now, as a Statistics undergrad, here is my opinion:
Ideally you should get more observations corresponding to AFTER, since you have 140 observations corresponding to BEFORE. If effect, you really have only n = 5 observations because your goal is to compare before vs after and you only have 5 observations related to after. If getting more after observations is not possible, then you should use some small-sample significante test, such as the t-test already mentioned. However, notice two things:
If you use the t-test, then you should use the paired version of the t-test because your observations correspond to before some treatment, and after some treatment.
The t-test is only appropriate if you assume that your sample data follows some t distribution (or, equivalently, approximately normal). So in order to use a significance t-test you'd first need to test your data to verify it follows a t distribution in the first place. If the latter test fails, you should use a non-parametric (distribution-free) paired test.
rose2904ks

rose2904ks

Beginner2022-06-24Added 3 answers

Thanks for the suggestions. Since acquiring more observations for the after condition is not possible, I will perform the tests you mentioned!

Do you have a similar question?

Recalculate according to your conditions!

New Questions in College Statistics

Ask your question.
Get an expert answer.

Let our experts help you. Answer in as fast as 15 minutes.

Didn't find what you were looking for?