Landauer's principle vs Wien's displacement lawCan we argue based on Landauer's principle that if one bit information is changed inside a blackbody, the total radiated energy should be at least or in order of kTln2? If it is so, can we also argue that this energy should be distributed over all the modes of the cavity? Furthermore, can it also be argued that this contradicts with the Wien's displacement law which says the total energy should be in the order of k T 4 h 4 (as integrated using Mathematica 8.0)?

Question

Landauer&#039;s principle vs Wien&#039;s displacement lawCan we argue based on Landauer&#039;s principle that if one bit information is changed inside a blackbody, the total radiated energy should be at least or in order of kTln2? If it is so, can we also argue that this energy should be distributed over all the modes of the cavity? Furthermore, can it also be argued that this contradicts with the Wien&#039;s displacement law which says the total energy should be in the order of   k            T      4              h      4       (as integrated using Mathematica 8.0)?

reflam2kfnr · Accepted Answer

&quot;Can we argue based on Landauer&#039;s principle that if one bit information is changed inside a blackbody, the total radiated energy should be at least or in order of kTln2?&quot;No, not really. Landauer&#039;s principle applies to erasing bits of a computer&#039;s memory, not changing bits. In general you do not need to emit heat to change bits, unless you want to do an irreversible operation such as erasing.On the other hand, black bodies must always emit heat according to the Stefan-Boltzmann law, regardless of whether there is a computer inside the black body erasing bits of its memory or not.This isn&#039;t to say that the two things are completely unrelated. It makes more physical sense to do the opposite calculation and say that if a black body is radiating heat at a rate   J  =  σ      T    4   then bits must be changing form at a rate   J  k  T  ln  ⁡  2  =  σ  k      T    3    ln  ⁡  2. These are bits of entropy that are being transferred from the motion of the molecules making up the body to degrees of freedom of the electromagnetic field.The radiated energy is distributed equally over all the modes of a black body. This is a fundamental assumption in Planck&#039;s derivation of the black body spectrum, and can pretty much be seen as the definition of a black body.Wien&#039;s displacement law is a property of the Planck spectrum, so it&#039;s hard to see how this can lead to a contradiction. But for anyone to give a good answer to this part of the question, I think you will need to give more details of how you arrived at your formula. For one thing it doesn&#039;t have the units of energy.

Landauer's principle vs Wien's displacement law Can we argue based on Landauer's principle that if

Answered question

Answer & Explanation

New Questions in Quantum Mechanics