What calorimetry approach is this?
Question:
Find the final tempertature of the system when
britesoulusjhq
Answered question
2022-04-07
What calorimetry approach is this? Question: Find the final tempertature of the system when of steam at is mized with ice at Constants: Specific heat of ice and specific heat of steam is Specific heat of water is Latent heat of fusion is Latent heat of vaporization is My attempt: I usually approach these problems by setting the final temperature as . Then, I equate heat lost by steam to heat gained by ice. I have been taught this method and I am adept at it. My problem: The solution given in my workbook is: Heat released when of steam at is cooled to is . Now, this heat is given to be given to of ice. This raises the temperature by This is a new method for me, and I am unable to understand it. I wish to know: How does this method work? In what calorimetry situations can this method be applied? NOTE: The final answer is
Answer & Explanation
ele5ph1a7jl1
Beginner2022-04-08Added 21 answers
The method used in the solution is to: 1.Bring all the constituents (in this case boiling hot steam and sub-zero ice) to a preselected and arbitrary point and calculate the heat flows (in or out) needed to achieve this for each component. In this case, you could pick all liquid water at C. 2.Add up all the individual heat flows to find the net heat flow needed to reach this assumed condition. 3.Finally, realize that there should be zero heat flow. So apply the necessary correction to the single combined mass of water, to find its final temperature and state. The problem with the method you prefer is that you might need to try many different final states to find the correct answer. For a very small amount of steam, you might assume that the ice warms up slightly to , while condensing the steam, cooling it from to , freezing all of it, and cooling it from to below zero. For a larger amount of steam, you might assume that the ice all warms up to while condensing all the steam, cooling it to , and then freezing grams of the condensed steam. For a still larger amount of steam, you might assume that the ice all warms up to while condensing all the steam, cooling it to , and then freezing grams of the condensed steam. For a still larger amount of steam, you might assume that the ice all warms up to and grams of it melts, while condensing all the steam and cooling it to For a still larger amount of steam you might assume that all the ice warms up to freezing, melts, and warms to , while all the steam condenses and cools to And for a really large amount of steam, you might assume that all the ice warms to freezing, melts, warms up to , while grams of the steam condenses. Each of these is possible, depending on the amount of ateam, and you have no way of knowing which one to try just by looking at the numbers. You need to try each one. Each produces a different linear equation in one unknown, so each will have a single mathematical solution. But only one of the solutions will be consistent with the assumptions that went into finding it. You might find values of that are negative, or too big for the amount of ice or steam actually present. You could assume all liquid water at , and find that is . You will need to keep trying scenario after scenario, to find the one that makes sense.
Stoyanovahvsbh
Beginner2022-04-09Added 3 answers
There is a difference between the masses in the question and those in the given answer. I assume the masses in the question are correct and those in the given answer are wrong. In this "method" you imagine that the of steam is converted to ice at C, so that it is the same as the of ice which is already at C. The thermal energy extracted is then used to heat of ice. This method works because thermodynamic energy changes are conservative like changes in gravitational potential energy. The difference in energy depends only on the initial and final states and not on the path taken. In your method you have two initial states and you assume a temperature for the final state. In this method you convert everything to the same initial state (because it is the same substance) then use the energy extracted to heat it up to the final state. If you are not happy with this method stick with your usual method, which will give you the same answer.