Why does solving the differential equation for circular motion lead to an illogical result?

Emmy Swanson

Emmy Swanson

Answered question

2022-10-20

In uniform circular motion, acceleration is expressed by the equation
a = v 2 r .

Answer & Explanation

Shyla Maldonado

Shyla Maldonado

Beginner2022-10-21Added 15 answers

That equation is misleading.
You wrongly assume that a is dv/dt here, which it isn't.
Let us first rewrite the centripetal acceleration equation properly:
| a N | = | v | 2 R a N = v 2 R
where a N is the normal acceleration. The normal acceleration can be expressed as a a T where a T is the tangential compenent of acceleration a. For uniform circular motion, a T = 0 so what we're left with is
| d v d t | = | v | 2 R a = v 2 R
Note that a here is a = a x 2 + a y 2 in 2-D. Since v = ( v x , v y ) , we can say
a = ( d v x d t ) 2 + ( d v y d t ) 2 .
Putting this into our centripital acceleration equation, we can get,
(*) ( d v x d t ) 2 + ( d v y d t ) 2 = v x 2 + v y 2 R
This is the proper differential equation we are solving.
Note that since a T = 0, we have that d d t | v | = d d t v x 2 + v y 2 = 0, so
v x a x + v y a y = v a = 0 , which serves as our second equation to solve ( ).
Now, since you know that the solution to uniform circular motion is r = ( R cos ( ω t ) , R sin ( ω t ) ), you can go ahead and verify that it indeed satisfies

Do you have a similar question?

Recalculate according to your conditions!

New Questions in Advanced Physics

Ask your question.
Get an expert answer.

Let our experts help you. Answer in as fast as 15 minutes.

Didn't find what you were looking for?