When does a function NOT have an antiderivative?I know this question may sound naïve but why can't we write ∫ e x 2 d x as ∫ e 2 x d x? The former does not have an antiderivative, while the latter has.In light of this question, what are sufficient conditions for a function NOT to have an antiderivative. That is, do we need careful examination of a function to say it does not have an antiderivative or is there any way that once you see the function, you can right away say it does not have an antiderivative?

Question

When does a function NOT have an antiderivative?I know this question may sound naïve but why can&#039;t we write   ∫      e                  x        2              d  x as   ∫      e          2      x        d  x? The former does not have an antiderivative, while the latter has.In light of this question, what are sufficient conditions for a function NOT to have an antiderivative. That is, do we need careful examination of a function to say it does not have an antiderivative or is there any way that once you see the function, you can right away say it does not have an antiderivative?

kejohananws · Accepted Answer

Step 1As you might have realised, exponentiation is not associative:            (              a        b            )        c    ≠      a          (              b        c            )      So what should       a                  b        c             mean? The convention is that exponentiation is right associative:      a                  b        c              =      a          (              b        c            )      Step 2Because the otherwise left-associative exponentiation is just less useful and redundant, as it can be represented by multiplication inside the power (again as you might have realised):      a          b      c        =            (              a        b            )        c

Finley Mckinney · Accepted Answer

Explanation:The exponential expression       a                  b        c             is equal to       a          (              b        c            )      . It is not equal to   (      a    b        )    c    =      a          b      ⋅      c       as you seem to think it is. In general an exponential is evaluated from right to left with the highest term evaluated first. That is to say                    x        0                              x            1                                          x                2                                  …                                                                                                        x                        n                                                                                                                                    =              x        0                              (                          x              1                                                (                                      x                    2                                                                  (                        …                                                                                                        (                                                          x                              n                                                        )                                                                          )                                                                              )                                                      )

When does a function NOT have an antiderivative? I know this question may sound naïve but why can't

Answered question

Answer & Explanation

New Questions in Calculus 1